The roles of the wait-and-see strategy and proactive Gamma Knife surgery (GKS) in the treatment paradigm for small intracanalicular vestibular schwannomas (VSs) is still a matter of debate, especially when patients present with functional hearing. The authors compare these 2 methods.
开云体育世界杯赔率
Forty-seven patients (22 men and 25 women) harboring an intracanalicular VS were followed prospectively. The mean age of the patients at the time of inclusion was 54.4 years (range 20–71 years). The mean follow-up period was 43.8 ± 40 months (range 9–222 months). Failure was defined as significant tumor growth and/or hearing deterioration that required microsurgical or radiosurgical treatment. This population was compared with a control group of 34 patients harboring a unilateral intracanalicular VS who were consecutively treated by GKS and had functional hearing at the time of radiosurgery.
Results
Of the 47 patients in the wait-and-see group, treatment failure (tumor growth requiring treatment) was observed in 35 patients (74%), although conservative treatment is still ongoing for 12 patients. Treatment failure in the control (GKS) group occurred in only 1 (3%) of 34 patients. In the wait-and-see group, there was no change in tumor size in 10 patients (21%), tumor growth in 36 patients (77%), and a mild decrease in tumor size in 1 patient (2%). Forty patients in the wait-and-see group were available for a hearing level study, which demonstrated no change in Gardner-Robertson hearing class for 24 patients (60%). Fifteen patients (38%) experienced more than 10 db of hearing loss and 2 of them became deaf. At 3, 4, and 5 years, the useful hearing preservation rates were 75%, 52%, and 41% in the wait-and-see group and 77%, 70%, and 64% in the control group, respectively. Thus, the chances of maintaining functional hearing and avoiding further intervention were much higher in cases treated by GKS (79% and 60% at 2 and 5 years, respectively) than in cases managed by the wait-and-see strategy (43% and 14% at 2 and 5 years, respectively).
Conclusions
These data indicate that the wait-and-see policy exposes the patient to elevated risks of tumor growth and degradation of hearing. Both events may occur independently in the mid-term period. This information must be presented to the patient. A careful sequential follow-up may be adopted when the wait-and-see strategy is chosen, but proactive GKS is recommended when hearing is still useful at the time of diagnosis. This recommendation may be a main paradigm shift in the practice of treating intracanalicular VSs.
Abbreviations used in this paper:
ABR = auditory brainstem response;GKS = Gamma Knife surgery;IAC =内部听觉运河;PTA = pure tone average;SDS =言语歧视得分;TDT = tumor doubling time;TGR diam. = tumor growth rate based on diameter;TGR vol. = tumor growth rate based on volume;VS = vestibular schwannoma.
Address correspondence to: Jean Régis, M.D., Service de Neurochirurgie Fonctionnelle et Stereotaxique, Hôpital d'adulte de la Timone, 264 rue Saint Pierre, 13385 Marseille Cedex 05, France. email:jregis@ap-hm.fr.
Bozorg GrayeliA,,KalamaridesM,,FerraryE,,BouccaraD,,El GharemH,&ReyA,et al.:Conservative management versus surgery for small vestibular schwannomas.Acta Otolaryngol125:1063–1068,2005
Bozorg Grayeli
A
,
Kalamarides
M
,
Ferrary
E
,
Bouccara
D
,
El Gharem
H
,
Rey
A
,
:
Conservative management versus surgery for small vestibular schwannomas
.Acta Otolaryngol
125
:
1063
–
1068
,
2005)| false
DeenHG,,EbersoldMJ,,HarnerSG,,BeattyCW,,MarionMS,&WharenRE,et al.:Conservative management of acoustic neuroma: an outcome study.开云体育app官方网站下载入口39:260–266,1996
Deen
HG
,
Ebersold
MJ
,
Harner
SG
,
Beatty
CW
,
Marion
MS
,
Wharen
RE
,
:
Conservative management of acoustic neuroma: an outcome study
.开云体育app官方网站下载入口
39
:
260
–
266
,
1996)| false
DelsantiC,,RochePH,,ThomassinJM,&RégisJ:Morphological changes of vestibular schwannomas after radiosurgical treatment: pitfalls and diagnosis of failure.Prog Neurol Surg21:93–97,2008
Delsanti
C
,
Roche
PH
,
Thomassin
JM
,
Régis
J
:
Morphological changes of vestibular schwannomas after radiosurgical treatment: pitfalls and diagnosis of failure
.Prog Neurol Surg
21
:
93
–
97
,
2008)| false
FuentesS,,ArkhaY,,Pech-GourgG,,GrisoliF,,DufourH,&RégisJ:Management of large vestibular schwannomas by combined surgical resection and gamma knife radiosurgery.Prog Neurol Surg21:79–82,2008
Fuentes
S
,
Arkha
Y
,
Pech-Gourg
G
,
Grisoli
F
,
Dufour
H
,
Régis
J
:
Management of large vestibular schwannomas by combined surgical resection and gamma knife radiosurgery
.Prog Neurol Surg
21
:
79
–
82
,
2008)| false
KoosWT,,DayJD,,MatulaC,&LevyDI:Neurotopographic considerations in the microsurgical treatment of small acoustic neurinomas.J Neurosurg88:506–512,1998
Koos
WT
,
Day
JD
,
Matula
C
,
Levy
DI
:
Neurotopographic considerations in the microsurgical treatment of small acoustic neurinomas
.J Neurosurg
88
:
506
–
512
,
1998)| false
MartinC,,PradesJM,,MayaudR,&ChelikL:Facteurs d'évolutivité des neurinomes de l'acoustique.JFORL J Fr Otorhinolaryngol41:18–22,1992
Martin
C
,
Prades
JM
,
Mayaud
R
,
Chelik
L
:
Facteurs d'évolutivité des neurinomes de l'acoustique
.JFORL J Fr Otorhinolaryngol
41
:
18
–
22
,
1992)| false
MyrsethE,,MøllerP,,PedersenPH,,VassbotnFS,,Wentzel-LarsenT,&Lund-JohansenM:Vestibular schwannomas: clinical results and quality of life after microsurgery or gamma knife radiosurgery.开云体育app官方网站下载入口56:927–935,2005
Myrseth
E
,
Møller
P
,
Pedersen
PH
,
Vassbotn
FS
,
Wentzel-Larsen
T
,
Lund-Johansen
M
:
Vestibular schwannomas: clinical results and quality of life after microsurgery or gamma knife radiosurgery
.开云体育app官方网站下载入口
56
:
927
–
935
,
2005)| false
PelletW,,RegisJ,,RochePH,&DelsantiC:Relative indications for radiosurgery and microsurgery for acoustic schwannoma.Adv Tech Stand Neurosurg28:227–284,2003
Pellet
W
,
Regis
J
,
Roche
PH
,
Delsanti
C
:
Relative indications for radiosurgery and microsurgery for acoustic schwannoma
.Adv Tech Stand Neurosurg
28
:
227
–
284
,
2003)| false
PollockBE,,DriscollCL,,FooteRL,,LinkMJ,,GormanDA,&BauchCD,et al.:Patient outcomes after vestibular schwannoma management: a prospective comparison of microsurgical resection and stereotactic radiosurgery.开云体育app官方网站下载入口59:77–85,2006
Pollock
BE
,
Driscoll
CL
,
Foote
RL
,
Link
MJ
,
Gorman
DA
,
Bauch
CD
,
:
Patient outcomes after vestibular schwannoma management: a prospective comparison of microsurgical resection and stereotactic radiosurgery
.开云体育app官方网站下载入口
59
:
77
–
85
,
2006)| false
PollockBE,,LunsfordLD,,KondziolkaD,,FlickingerJC,,BissonetteDJ,&KelseySF,et al.:Outcome analysis of acoustic neuroma management: a comparison of microsurgery and stereotactic radiosurgery.开云体育app官方网站下载入口36:215–229,1995
Pollock
BE
,
Lunsford
LD
,
Kondziolka
D
,
Flickinger
JC
,
Bissonette
DJ
,
Kelsey
SF
,
:
Outcome analysis of acoustic neuroma management: a comparison of microsurgery and stereotactic radiosurgery
.开云体育app官方网站下载入口
36
:
215
–
229
,
1995)| false
RautVV,,WalshRM,,BathAP,,BanceML,,GuhaA,&TatorCH,et al.:Conservative management of vestibular schwannomas—second review of a prospective longitudinal study.Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci29:505–514,2004
Raut
VV
,
Walsh
RM
,
Bath
AP
,
Bance
ML
,
Guha
A
,
Tator
CH
,
:
Conservative management of vestibular schwannomas—second review of a prospective longitudinal study
.Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci
29
:
505
–
514
,
2004)| false
RégisJ,,PelletW,,DelsantiC,,DufourH,,RochePH,&ThomassinJM,et al.:Functional outcome after gamma knife surgery or microsurgery for vestibular schwannomas.J Neurosurg97:1091–1100,2002
Régis
J
,
Pellet
W
,
Delsanti
C
,
Dufour
H
,
Roche
PH
,
Thomassin
JM
,
:
Functional outcome after gamma knife surgery or microsurgery for vestibular schwannomas
.J Neurosurg
97
:
1091
–
1100
,
2002)| false
RégisJ,,RochePH,,DelsantiC,,SoumareO,,ThomassinJM,&PelletW,Stereotactic radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma.PollockBE:Contemporary Stereotactic Radiosurgery: Technique and EvaluationArmonk, NY,Futura Publishing Company,2002.181–212
Régis
J
,
Roche
PH
,
Delsanti
C
,
Soumare
O
,
Thomassin
JM
,
Pellet
W
,
Stereotactic radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma
.
Pollock
BE
:Contemporary Stereotactic Radiosurgery: Technique and Evaluation
Armonk, NY
,
Futura Publishing Company
,
2002
.
181
–
212)| false
RégisJ,,TamuraM,,DelsantiC,,RochePH,,PelletW,&ThomassinJM:Hearing preservation in patients with unilateral vestibular schwannoma after gamma knife surgery.Prog Neurol Surg21:142–151,2008
Régis
J
,
Tamura
M
,
Delsanti
C
,
Roche
PH
,
Pellet
W
,
Thomassin
JM
:
Hearing preservation in patients with unilateral vestibular schwannoma after gamma knife surgery
.Prog Neurol Surg
21
:
142
–
151
,
2008)| false
SoumareO:Schwannomes vestibulaires intra-canalaires: histoire naturelle et prise en charge. Contribution a propos de 76 patients.Thèse de MédecineMarseille,2000.151
Soumare
O
:
Schwannomes vestibulaires intra-canalaires: histoire naturelle et prise en charge. Contribution a propos de 76 patients
.Thèse de Médecine
Marseille
,
2000
.
151)| false
StangerupSE,,TosM,,Caye-ThomasenP,,TosT,,KlokkerM,&ThomsenJ:Increasing annual incidence of vestibular schwannoma and age at diagnosis.J Laryngol Otol118:622–627,2004
Stangerup
SE
,
Tos
M
,
Caye-Thomasen
P
,
Tos
T
,
Klokker
M
,
Thomsen
J
:
Increasing annual incidence of vestibular schwannoma and age at diagnosis
.J Laryngol Otol
118
:
622
–
627
,
2004)| false
StangerupSE,,TosM,,ThomsenJ,&Caye-ThomasenP:Hearing outcomes of vestibular schwannoma patients managed with ‘wait and scan’: predictive value of hearing level at diagnosis.J Laryngol Otol124:490–494,2010
Stangerup
SE
,
Tos
M
,
Thomsen
J
,
Caye-Thomasen
P
:
Hearing outcomes of vestibular schwannoma patients managed with ‘wait and scan’: predictive value of hearing level at diagnosis
.J Laryngol Otol
124
:
490
–
494
,
2010)| false
SughrueME,,KaneAJ,,KaurR,,BarryJJ,,RutkowskiMJ,&PittsLH,et al.:A prospective study of hearing preservation in untreated vestibular schwannomas. Clinical article.J Neurosurg[epub ahead of print May 21, 2010. DOI: 10.3171/2010.4.JNS091962]
Sughrue
ME
,
Kane
AJ
,
Kaur
R
,
Barry
JJ
,
Rutkowski
MJ
,
Pitts
LH
,
:
A prospective study of hearing preservation in untreated vestibular schwannomas. Clinical article
.J Neurosurg
[epub ahead of print May 21, 2010. DOI: 10.3171/2010.4.JNS091962])| false
SughrueME,,YangI,,ArandaD,,LoboK,,PittsLH,&CheungSW,et al.:The natural history of untreated sporadic vestibular schwannomas: a comprehensive review of hearing outcomes. Clinical article.J Neurosurg112:163–167,2010
Sughrue
ME
,
Yang
I
,
Aranda
D
,
Lobo
K
,
Pitts
LH
,
Cheung
SW
,
:
The natural history of untreated sporadic vestibular schwannomas: a comprehensive review of hearing outcomes. Clinical article
.J Neurosurg
112
:
163
–
167
,
2010)| false
TamuraM,,CarronR,,YomoS,,ArkhaY,,MuraciolleX,&PorcheronD,et al.:Hearing preservation after gamma knife radiosurgery for vestibular schwannomas presenting with high-level hearing.开云体育app官方网站下载入口64:289–296,2009
Tamura
M
,
Carron
R
,
Yomo
S
,
Arkha
Y
,
Muraciolle
X
,
Porcheron
D
,
:
Hearing preservation after gamma knife radiosurgery for vestibular schwannomas presenting with high-level hearing
.开云体育app官方网站下载入口
64
:
289
–
296
,
2009)| false
